Southern Australian farmgate milk prices for the fiscal 2027 season are broadly similar to the closing prices of the prior season, per the Australian Dairy Products Federation. The commodity milk value, a proxy for Bega’s (ASX.BGA) bulk business’ selling price, is about 15% lower than this time last year.

Why it matters: We think profitability in bulk has normalized. The farmgate milk price is the key input for Bega’s bulk business, which processes commodity milk. Milk is also a crucial input for Bega’s branded products like Dairy Farmers fresh milk and Bega cheese.

  • We estimate the farmgate prices will average about 4% less than last year over the course of the full year. With a lower commodity milk price, rationalized processing supply, and higher processing input costs, we think competition for milk is lower than last year.
  • We make no changes to our forecasts. We think fiscal 2027 represents a “normal” year for bulk. While our valuation is underpinned by average profitability, we expect bulk earnings to be more volatile in reality. Bega is a price taker, vulnerable to volatile input and selling prices.

The bottom line: Bega shares are expensive compared with our unchanged $4.60 fair value estimate. We think the market is too optimistic on long-term margin expansion, particularly in the branded business.

  • Bega relies heavily on demand from its powerful supermarket customers. Despite owning some well-known brands like Vegemite, we think Bega lacks sufficient brand equity to command substantial pricing power and has no economic moat.
  • We expect major supermarkets to leverage their formidable purchasing power to curtail price growth, limiting margin upside. We forecast EBITDA margins to expand to 6.6% by fiscal 2030, from about 6.0% in fiscal 2026 and 5.7% last year.

Between the lines: Australian farmgate prices and global milk commodity prices don’t necessarily align, creating swings in profitability for bulk processing.

Bega’s Brands Lack Sufficient Pricing Power to Generate Excess Returns

Despite Bega Group’s strategic shift toward a more diverse product offering, we expect dairy products to continue to represent the majority of sales over the next decade, exposing the company to commodity pricing and volatile input costs. We do not think Bega has carved an economic moat required to consistently generate economic profits, and we expect its powerful customers to limit margin growth potential.

Bega has transformed from a dairy processor with a focus on business-to-business operations to a branded consumer food company with a more diversified earnings base and less exposure to volatile milk prices. While dairy will remain a key category for Bega, the focus will be on high-value products such as cream cheese and infant formula. As part of the Lion Dairy & Drinks acquisition in 2021, Bega acquired leading brands in milk-based beverages and yogurt, white milk, and plant-based beverages, in addition to 13 manufacturing sites and Australia’s largest national cold chain distribution network.

We expect revenue growth in the branded segment, which includes spreads, grocery products, and Lion’s dairy and drinks portfolio, to be underpinned by new products and bolt-on acquisitions. There are no switching costs in the consumer foods category, and the rising adoption of online shopping has made it easier for smaller, niche brands to take share as physical shelf space becomes less relevant. This reinforces the need for Bega to invest in its brands to maintain share. Historically, Bega has made limited investment in its brands, particularly in Australia, where Fonterra is the licensee of the Bega brand. However, since acquiring the spreads and grocery business in 2018, marketing spending as a proportion of revenue has increased to about 3% from 1%, and we anticipate it to remain at the higher level.

Bulls Say

  • Bega Group’s strategic shift away from dairy products lowers its exposure to volatile milk prices and diversifies earnings.
  • Bega has scope to improve margins through participating in industry consolidation, maximizing plant utilization, and rationalizing operations after several acquisitions in recent years.
  • Bega is shifting investment to the spreads business, which we view as less commoditized and higher-margin than dairy, with strong niche positions in Vegemite and peanut butter.

Bears Say

  • Changing consumer trends toward dairy-free and vegan diets could lead to declines in per capita dairy and cheese consumption, weighing on the majority of Bega’s earnings.
  • Bega is at risk of losing market share to branded peers, niche operators, and private-label products due to the commoditized nature of its products.
  • External factors outside Bega’s control, such as weather, can adversely affect commodity prices, interrupting the firm’s supply chain and leading to volatile earnings.

Subscribe to get Morningstar insights in your inbox