Investors and dealmakers preparing for SpaceX’s upcoming $1.75 trillion IPO must reckon with one of the most powerful—and dangerous—variables in public equities: the Musk Effect.

Tesla’s TSLA stock history offers a lesson in this dynamic, as PitchBook’s SpaceX pre-IPO report explains. Since 2017, we have identified 99 major events that moved the electric vehicle leader’s stock 7% or more on elevated volume. About 6 in 10 were driven by company-specific catalysts. Corporate governance and political events, almost all of which trace directly to Musk, produced average moves of nearly 12%, statistically indistinguishable from earnings reactions, and skewed heavily negative.

The Musk premium cuts both ways. Tesla rallied over 90% in the month following the 2024 presidential election on the “Trump Musk trade,” only to surrender those gains entirely by March 2025 as DOGE backlash, European boycotts, and a 49% collapse in China sales converged.

SpaceX’s unconventional offering could amplify these dynamics. The company plans to float roughly 3%-4% of its equity (the thinnest large-cap float in modern history), meaning Musk-driven sentiment shifts hit a much narrower order book. Where Tesla sees 10%-15% swings on governance and political catalysts, PitchBook expects SpaceX to experience 20%-30% moves on equivalent news.

Another factor is the company’s credibility gap with investors, which is also familiar to Tesla shareholders. SpaceX management typically delivers on its targets, but only 1 in 5 get done on time. The rest run two to three years late. Shareholders will price this pattern through a kind of credibility ledger, discounting management timelines by 1.5 times-2.5 times while maintaining directional conviction.

SpaceX’s IPO will test everyone whose reputation rides on it. Bankers must price a company whose controlling shareholder can move markets with a few words. Management must ground its guidance in tighter, more defensible ranges than it has historically delivered. Institutional investors must decide how much Musk-driven volatility they can stomach. None of them have an easy job.

Subscribe to get Morningstar insights in your inbox