Treasury Wine Estates (ASX.TWE) has identified 10 key brands to focus on and invest in, and is undergoing a strategic review of its struggling US business. Also, it guides to fiscal 2026 underlying EBIT of $480 million-$490 million, and fiscal 2027 underlying EBIT at least the same.

Why it matters: We lower our fiscal 2026 underlying EBIT forecast by 2% to $487 million. But we materially cut our longer-term forecasts, mostly on commercial wine exits. We lower our fiscal 2027 EBIT forecast by 13% to $497 million, and our fiscal 2028 forecast by 24% to $513 million.

  • Three “power brands”: Penfolds, DAOU, and Matua will now get the bulk of investment. They generate 25% of volume, but 72% of gross profit. The seven additional “regional heroes,” like Frank Family and Squealing Pig, about 10% of volume and gross profit, will receive less attention and funding.
  • Brands outside the top 10 are thoroughly deprioritized, and the company flagged potential divestments. We think buyers will be hard to find as consumers increasingly snub cheaper wines. Indeed, the company previously failed to find a buyer for struggling brands like Yellowglen.

The bottom line: We lower our fair value estimate for Treasury by 18% to $7 per share. The reduction is based on lower earnings at midcycle following commercial wine exits over the next two years and lower midcycle profitability. Shares are cheap.

  • While dilutive to our valuation, commercial exits allow increased focus and investment in Treasury’s high-priced, high-margin brands. Despite lacking an economic moat in aggregate, we think increased focus on its strongest brands should strengthen Treasury’s competitive position.
  • The market liked the strategy update, with shares up 13% on the day. Nevertheless, we think it is overestimating weak wine demand and reduced shipments to distributors in the US, and China overhangs. We believe those headwinds are temporary and expect earnings to improve from fiscal 2028.

Despite Some Strong Brands, Treasury Lacks an Economic Moat

Treasury Wine Estates is increasingly focusing on building high-end brands in its portfolio, particularly in luxury and premium wine. With this focus, the company’s revenue from higher-end wines has risen above 80% in fiscal 2025 from less than half in early 2014, both from growth in its higher-end products and purposeful reduction of low-end, or commercial, wine sales.

Treasury has identified 10 key brands to receive the bulk of focus and investment. Most advertising and promotional investment will focus on three “power brands”: Penfolds, DAOU, and Matua. Seven additional “regional heroes”, like Frank Family and Squealing Pig, will receive lower relative investment. Brands outside the top 10 are set to be deprioritized, and we think exits are likely.

In recent years, global wine consumption has proven sluggish, but high-priced wines have bucked this trend, with luxury volumes growing at mid- to high-single-digit rates in developed regions such as Australia and the US, per company estimates.

Treasury also faces risks from unfavorable weather effects, sensitivity to the consumer cycle, and inelastic industry supply that frequently results in wine gluts or shortages. That said, the diversity of Treasury’s grape and bulk wine supply should significantly mitigate these concerns. And bringing in a significant proportion of its grape and bulk wine from outside suppliers increases the proportion of variable costs and ensures a lower-cost supply in times of surplus.

But we don’t think Treasury’s volume share gains and positive mix shift support strong enough brand assets to offset industry fragmentation, a proliferation of branded offerings, limited customer switching costs, and potential for changing consumer tastes. As such, despite a strong position in Australia, the company will likely continue to combat competitive pricing and promotional activity globally.

Bulls Say

  • Wine consumption growth in Asia should continue growing at high rates over the long run, and is a high-margin business for Treasury given a focus on luxury and midrange wine.
  • Treasury’s focus on higher-priced wine than in the past puts the company on-trend in global wine, and should drive substantial earnings growth as profitability expands.
  • Additions of new high-end wine brands, either organically or through acquisition, drive better grape utilization, improving margins, and higher ROICs.

Bears Say

  • Treasury is constantly battling with industry oversupply as wine consumption volumes continue to decline annually.
  • Treasury should enjoy rising profitability, but operating margins will likely continue to trail those of industry leaders, evidence of the firm’s lack of durable cost advantage.
  • Wine companies face high working-capital investment, particularly in inventory, and the risk of aged wine inventory falling in value before its sale.

The full report and picks list is available to Morningstar Investor subscribers and trialists.

Subscribe to get Morningstar insights in your inbox